Fluidity is a necessary element to any sporting success these days. Whether that be goalkeepers in Gaelic football venturing up field to score, defenders taking goal kicks in soccer or right handed golfers occasionally having to strike off the opposite side.
Rugby, though, was the one arena where regimented uniformity was all but guaranteed. For example, you couldn’t exactly envisage putting Nick Poppelwell or Peter Clohessy out on the wing, now, could you? Keith Wood – a different story. As well as being a world class hooker, his ‘day job’ in rugby terms, the Garryowen great was probably the first rugby forward to kick the ball. Let alone score a drop goal.
Woody was, and the following is meant in the most complimentary terms possible, too good of a rugby footballer to be confined to the rudiments of his appointed rule. But then, Uncle Fester wasn’t the first Irish player to go outside the box of their so called area of expertise.
After all, for one of their Triple Crown triumphs – either 1982 or 1985 – wasn’t it Michael Kiernan playing at centre who kicked the crucial drop goal against England. When, at the time, outside of the fly half and the full back, rugby players didn’t kick the ball.
However, even allowing for the above, Leo Cullen still flung an extraordinary curve ball a few weeks back when giving Dan Sheehan a run out in the back row. Now, if there was any Irish player to give a run at a different role, it would be Sheehan. The nearest there has been to the Killaloe colossus since his playing days.
Incidentally, while, in the aftermath of Cullen casting the dice at ‘club’ level there was a certain inevitability about Farrell following suit in camp green, one would have thought that the matches against either Argentina or the Fijians would have been the time to pull such a rabbit from a hat.

So, with Farrell having taken the plunge now in that regard, presumably the question must be asked, does his genuinely think Sheehan has more to offer from the back of the scrum than where he is arguably the best practitioner of his craft on the planet, or is it that he feels Sheehan is better than all the other options available to him?
If it’s the latter, that would be very harsh on those within the squad who specialise in that area of the pitch – and Nick Timoney in particular. Still, there’s a third angle from which the experiment must be viewed knowing that the basis for the South African game is bulldozing dominance of the scrum, you do wonder what sort of signal it sends to a crowd who revel in getting inside the heads of opponents. Taking the best hooker in the world out of his natural habitat.
True, it could of course be seen as a ringing endorsement of Ronan Kelleher – not unwarranted either – but it will probably boil down as either a very dangerous gamble or an accidental masterstroke. Only time will tell.
Ireland – H. Keenan; R. Baloucoune, R. Henshaw, S. McCloskey, M. Hansen; S. Prendergast, J. Gibson-Park; A. Porter, R. Kelleher, T. Furlong; J. McCarthy, T. Beirne; R. Baird, J. van der Flier, D. Sheehan (Capt.)
Replacements – T. O’Toole, T. Stewart, T. Clarkson, J. Ryan, N. Timoney, C. Casey, C. Frawley, B. Aki.

Leave a Reply